Neonatal Diabetes: When the Diagnosis Doesn't Fit

           

Mother holding her infant son in a blue outfit indoors before his diabetes diagnosis.

 

            When the Hoofbeats Don't Sound Like Horses

"When you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras."

This is a saying that has been taught to medical students for years in reference to rare diseases. Rare, by definition, does not occur often enough for most doctors to encounter certain conditions EVER in the span of their careers. So when a pediatrician sees a baby who is nursing a lot, peeing a lot, and is very colicky, instead of seeing something wrong with the baby, they immediately see s worried mother, or a fussy baby. "These things just happen," are the typical responses we heard from our doctors in those first few months of Andy's life.

When Andy came down with his first cold, and then lost more than three pounds, I panicked. At Andy's four-month check-up, the doctor gave me a lecture, telling me I wasn't feeding Andy enough. According to him, Andy hadn't gained any weight since his two-month visit. I argued with him, telling him that Andy had weighed over thirteen pounds when I weighed him on my scale at home when he was three months old. The doctor flipped his hand in the air and proclaimed that home bathroom scales were not that reliable and then proceeded to tell me that I needed to add cereal to Andy's diet and start attending nutrition classes myself.

I left that visit in tears, feeling like I was the problem. I felt like I had failed my son somehow by not giving him the proper nutrition and now he was sick because of it. It's so sad that we allow doctors to hold a place of power over our lives like that. As mothers, I feel like we do it even more, especially when it comes to our children. But even as bad as that experience was, I didn't have enough information to know how to change the system, or even how to help Andy yet.

A Diagnosis That Didn't Quite Fit

A few weeks later, after several other doctor visits and many other incorrect diagnoses, Andy ended up in the emergency room on his death bed. I won't go into a long explanation here on the blog, but at four months old, Andy's blood sugar was over 1200, he was in diabetic ketoacidosis, and if we had not taken him to the ER the day we did, he might have died in his sleep.

After a long process of elimination, on August 24, 2005, the doctors and nurses finally agreed that Andy had, what was an unusually young onset of Type 1 diabetes. The endocrinologist ultimately called Andy's diabetes idiopathic Type 1 diabetes because of some unusual findings:

  • Andy was negative for all of the autoimmune biomarkers
  • He required lower insulin requirements than expected for his weight (even as he grew)
  • His C-peptide results indicated continued insulin production

The C-peptide test result was the indicator that surprised the doctor the most. Because that was evidence that his body was still producing its own insulin, they couldn't understand why Andy was still having high blood sugars. The endocrinologist told us that it might be a honeymoon period and to watch out for periods of low blood sugars just in case his body kicked in and started working again. I didn't even know that was a possibility, but I guess it happens sometimes.

Infant Andy lying on a blanket and holding a baby bottle after his Type I diabetes diagnosis.

It never did though. We did have occasional low blood sugars, but overall, it was just a roller coaster. Dan and I searched the internet for other families like ours, but turned up very little. Eventually, we did discover some information about babies on insulin pumps and we were able to get one for Andy just before his first birthday. That did help smooth out his wild blood sugar swings, but the financial stress was by far the biggest worry on our plate. So to ease that burden, we ended up moving to a different state for Dan to take on a better job.

The Doctor Who Connected the Dots

Almost as soon as we moved to North Carolina, our lives changed drastically. Dan's job was going well, I got a great job teaching fifth grade at a nearby school, and Andy's endocrinologist was amazing. He actually sat and listened to me before giving his opinion. He asked me questions and was genuinely curious about all of Andy's symptoms and how he was doing. But beyond that, he trusted me with Andy's care. He actually asked me how I was doing and if there was anything I needed to make Andy's care any easier.

I felt like I was talking to a colleague at school instead of a doctor who believed he knew more than me.

Smiling toddler Andy in a camouflage shirt after diagnosis, with his insulin pump visible as part of his diabetes treatment.

The very next month, an article was published in a medical journal that would end up changing not only Andy's life, but that of an entire population of patients in the diabetes world. It turns out that there is a small percentage of patients who, if diagnosed with diabetes under the age of six months old, might be able to trade insulin treatment for a pill. The reason is the cause of their diabetes.

Our doctor told us that in the majority of patients diagnosed in infancy, the cause is a genetic mutation, and not autoimmune. If Andy had one of the genetic mutations that responded to the pill, he might be able to come completely off of insulin. So our doctor suggested genetic testing. Dan and I were ecstatic. The doctor said he was "cautiously optimistic".

The blood draw was horrible, as most were for Andy at that time in his life. That was the middle of November, just before Thanksgiving, so we had to wait all through the holidays for the results. We thought it was going to be a four week wait, but four turned into five as Christmas came and went. Then we celebrated the beginning of the year, ringing in 2007 without any news.

The Phone Call that Changed Everything

As soon as I went back to school for the teacher work day at the beginning of January, I received a phone call. We were sitting in the school library for professional development when my phone rang. I looked at the phone number. Recognizing my endocrinologist's number, I quietly stepped out into the hallway to answer the phone.

"I have good news," he said, "Andy's genetic test came back. He tested positive for the KCNJ11 gene with the Val59Met mutation. That gene is one of the most common genes with mutations causing neonatal diabetes. The Val59Met is a more rare mutation. But I am cautiously optimistic that Andy will be able to completely come off of insulin. I do, however, want to admit him to the hospital to do this so I can observe him closely if you agree to switch the treatment."

I could hardly breathe. The letters, numbers, and new vocabulary swimming through my mind in a cacophony of chaos. Like a symphony playing out of tune, I just couldn't make sense of it all. I was dizzy from the onslaught of information and forced myself to say, "Yes," and "Thank you," before scheduling an appointment with him and heading back into my meeting in a daze.

Five Days That Changed His Treatment

Timeline infographic showing Andy’s neonatal diabetes journey from his August 24, 2005 diagnosis through genetic testing in 2006 and his insulin-free milestone on January 24, 2007.

January 21, 2007, we were admitted to the hospital to transition Andy off of insulin and onto this revolutionary new treatment. The odd thing was this was not a revolutionary new pill, it was just a new type of diabetes for which the drug was being applied. Sulfonylureas have been used since the 1950s for Type 2 diabetics and the drug we would be using on Andy, glyburide, had been available as a Type 2 diabetic generic drug in the United States since 1984.

However, we were about to give these pills to a toddler who was just over twenty-one months old. He was barely walking. Not talking yet. Besides checking his blood sugar, we had no way of knowing if his blood sugar was crashing. So with an abundance of caution, Andy's medical team wanted to monitor his blood glucose closely and have him close enough to administer sugar intravenously, and quickly, if needed.

Monday morning we started the first pill and lowered the amount of insulin with his breakfast. By lunchtime, Andy's blood sugar was already showing signs of responding to the pill. Yet, I held my breath, not ready to believe in the miracle.

Wednesday morning, as I drove to the hospital with my sister-in-law, Dan called us with the news that he had disconnected Andy's pump. I screamed with excitement. It was short-lived, however, when lunchtime came and went and Andy's glyburide still had not been delivered by the pharmacy. As his blood sugar started to climb, our doctor advised us to reconnect the pump to administer a small dose of insulin while he sent a nurse down to the pharmacy to pick up the pill. So both Dan and I had the honor of disconnecting the pump the final time.

I count January 24, 2007 as Andy's last day of insulin. Seventeen months to the day after his official diabetes diagnosis, Andy's life changed yet again. To this day, we believe that Andy was likely the third patient in the United States to transition off of insulin as a neonatal diabetes patient. After him, it was a snowball of other patients coming off and learning about this new type of diabetes.

Neonatal Diabetes Was an Answer, Not the End of the Story

Once we were discharged from the hospital, Dan and I had what I call a type of second "baby honeymoon" where we felt like we had our baby back. We believed what we had just experienced was a miracle. And it was. In so many ways. I will forever be grateful that I don't have to administer insulin or connect insulin pumps or continuous glucose monitors. Hell, I don't even have to check his blood sugars as much anymore because he is so stable now.

What we didn't know was what the V59M mutation also caused in addition to the diabetes. While there was information at that time, it took a while to trickle down to me as a mother. It took time for me to learn what I was watching in front of me as Andy developed. I was watching my son walk and learn to run. But he was still not talking. He was still struggling with fine motor skills, some feeding skills, and some extremely odd behaviors that were escalating to the point of harming others.

We also learned that there were other genes and mutations that did not respond to the treatment so we discovered that we were one of the lucky families who got to come off of insulin. But I still felt alone because our doctor requested that we not share our story beyond our immediate family.

It took years before we were able to find more families and discover that there were more conditions associated with Andy's diabetes. By the time Katie came along in 2009, I was starting to find other families in the neonatal diabetes community and spread the word about this rare condition. By the time I met those families in person in 2010, we knew about DEND syndrome and all of the other parts that were possibilities in the future.

We hoped that our children would be spared some of the conditions, like epilepsy, but that showed up later, and in ways we were not even expecting. But that is a story for a different time.

Sometimes the Hoofbeats Really Are Zebras

A zebra facing the camera with two other zebras behind it in a grassy landscape.

Thinking back on Andy's story, it is not lost on me how close we came to losing him that night in August of 2005. I am also well aware that if Andy had died that night, Dan and I would have had no idea what would have caused it. Through my obsessive research over the years, I discovered that, at the time, even if they did test for certain markers for diabetes post-mortem on a baby who died due to SIDS, the findings would not have led them to a diagnosis of neonatal diabetes. Only a genetic test would have revealed that and only if they were looking specifically for it.

Also, because we later discovered that one of us is a carrier for the gene in our reproductive cells, a condition called germline mosaicism, any future children we had would have succumbed to the same circumstances. Granted, with the rapidly growing research, the outcome might have been different. Who knows.

I say all that because I want to convey that I think it is important that doctors listen to patients and/or their caregivers/parents. Too often, in my experience as a patient and a caregiver, I felt like I was being ushered through a factory line. Waiting room, exam room, blood work, checklist, done. Move on. Don't question why symptoms are being experienced in connection with each other. Don't question why symptoms can or can't be possible in a patient of a certain age even if they are so obviously pointing to a certain diagnosis.

Doctors also need to be willing to set aside their biases and be willing to believe in the unusual. Just because a condition is rare, doesn't mean it's impossible. Every rare disease or condition started with the discovery of one patient. You never know when you will find the next new genetic change.

And please, if you are a pediatric endocrinologist, make sure you are testing all patients who were diagnosed under the age of six months. If you are an adult endocrinologist, when is the last time you asked your adult patient with diabetes what age they were diagnosed? Did you know that some patients with neonatal diabetes can have something called transient neonatal diabetes? That happens when they are diagnosed as a baby and it goes away within a few months to a few years then comes back later in life. There are all kinds. Look it up.

What I Hope Other Families Take Away

Parents, don't be afraid to share observations of your child and their symptoms, behaviors, and reactions, even if it seems benign. Write down your questions between doctor visits. Believe me, you won't remember once you get there. If something seems odd, out of place, or if your child doesn't seem to be meeting milestones on time or losing skills they once had, write it down and ask about it. No question is too small to ask. You never know when something you notice will lead to an answer or a diagnosis. Videotape if you need to for evidence to show your doctor if something is hard to describe.

Medical professionals, remain curious when the symptoms don't seem to fit the expected pattern. Don't try to put a bandage on it or throw a quick diagnosis just to get a parent out of your office because they have been there "too many times". Sometimes the squeaky wheel is there because something really is wrong. Not because they are "just a new worried parent".

For the general public, go learn about other forms of diabetes. November is National Diabetes Month to raise awareness about diabetes prevention, education, and management. In the United States, it impacts roughly 38 million people. Not all of those are affected by Type 1 and Type 2. Go learn about gestational diabetes, neonatal, LADA, MODY, and so many more. Some are treated with insulin, some with pills, some with diet alone, and some are getting stem-cell treatments now.

To learn more about neonatal diabetes and our family's story, you can read my memoir Twice Rare: A Memoir of Rare Genes, Relentless Advocacy, and Being Seen. There are also other resources here on our site to explore.

What about you? Have you ever encountered a medical situation in which the initial explanation didn't fit the evidence?



Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published